Are you looking at your window replacement options? Are you finding that making a choice between a full frame replacement or a window insert replacement is overwhelming? Homeowners often find making this decision challenging, so you are not alone. Let’s take a look at full frame vs insert window replacement and get you the information you need to make the right decision for your home.
One of the first things to understand when learning how to choose between full frame and insert windows is what is meant by each of these terms.
Full-Frame Replacement: What is it?
In a Nutshell
A full-frame window replacement is much what the name suggests. It is the process of removing the entirety of your old, existing window, including the frame and sash, all the way down to the studs, leaving the full wall opening exposed. Then, a new window, frame and all is installed in the opening.
Weighing the Pros and Cons
As with any home improvement project, this process has its pros and cons.
The Pros
Improved Energy Efficiency
Upgrading to more energy efficient windows can be an effective way to cut your home’s heating and cooling costs, proving to be a long-term investment that can pay dividends down the line.
An Opportunity for Change
If you want to change the size, shape, or style of your windows, then a full window replacement is the way to go.
Address Issues with Existing Frame
If your frame is damaged or rotting, a full window replacement can address the causes and repair the damage, making replacement a necessary home improvement project to maintain the integrity of your home’s construction.
The Cons
High cost
Window replacement is a major home improvement project that comes with a price tag that can be cost prohibitive.
Disruptive installation
Removing existing windows, exposing the wall opening, and sometimes changing the size of the opening is not a quick or easy process. It takes time and will disrupt your home life for the project’s duration.
Can Expose the Need for More Work
Once your existing window is removed and the wall opening is exposed the window replacement project can require more work on either the exterior or interior parts of your home, extending the project beyond the windows.
Insert Window Replacement: What is it?
In a Nutshell
A window insert replacement keeps the existing frame intact and does not require exposing the window opening. The process removes the existing window sash and glass, but not the frame, and replaces it with a new window sash and glass inserted into the existing frame.
Weighing the Pros and Cons
Since we weighed the pros and cons of a full window replacement, let’s also weigh the pros and cons of insert window replacement.
The Pros
Lower Cost
A Window insert replacement is a simpler process that requires less materials and labor, which also translates to a lower cost than a full replacement.
Faster and Less Invasive Installation
The simpler process of a window insert replacement when compared to a full frame replacement also makes it a faster and less invasive installation project.
Preserves Existing Trim
This can be important if you want to maintain the original style of your home and preserve either its historical construction or aesthetic value.
The Cons
Slightly Reduced Glass Area
Window inserts can reduce the glass surface area in your window, making them let in slightly less light.
Won’t Fix Severely Damaged Frames
Window insert replacement is not going to fix rotted or damaged frames or repair structural issues causing the damage.
Possible Lower Energy Efficiency
Window inserts are not necessarily going to provide the same energy efficiency value as a full replacement. Although there are high-quality window inserts, like those manufactured by Climate Seal, that provide high thermal performance, allowing you to improve your home’s energy efficiency without the higher cost of a full replacement.
Full Frame Vs Window Insert Replacement: A Head-to-Head Comparison
Key Differences Between Full-frame and Insert Window Replacement
Full-frame Replacement | Insert Window Replacement | |
COST | $66-$109/square foot | $21-$44/square foot |
INSTALLATION TIME | 2-6 hours/window | About an hour/window |
ENERGY SAVINGS | $125-$465 per year* | 20% average savings on energy costs |
AESTHETICS | Design choice flexibility | Limited to existing frame |
LONGEVITY | Address issues with the home’s structural integrity | Does not address the age or weather damage of the existing frame |
*Department of Energy estimate.
Full Frame Vs. Insert Window Replacement: When to Choose Each Option
Some situations are better suited for full-frame replacement, while others are more easily remedied with insert window replacement. Let’s take a look at when to choose each option.
Choose Full-Frame Replacement If…
Need to Replace Existing Frames
If your window frames are rotten or damaged, it is time for a full-frame replacement. The situation is not going away and it won’t be remedied by window inserts. Getting an inspection to evaluate your existing frames is recommended.
Want to Change Window Styles
If you want to turn your regular sized window into a large picture window by opening up your existing window opening, then a full-frame window replacement will allow you to do that. It also allows for changing your window shape or style.
Need Maximum Energy Efficiency
There are a lot of new energy efficient windows on the market and if you are looking to maximize the energy efficiency in your home then a full new window installation can be the way to go. High quality window inserts designed with energy efficiency and high thermal performance are worth checking out as they could give you the energy efficiency you are looking for at a fraction of the price.
Increase Home Value
New, high-end windows, trendy styles, or upgraded window sizes that change your home’s curb appeal, can increase your home’s value. It is an investment worth weighing if you are looking to take on this type of home improvement project.
Choose Window Insert Replacement If…
Existing Frames Are in Good Condition
Window inserts are a good option if your existing frames are in good condition. There is no need to replace the existing frame because of needing to repair structural damage. It is an expense you do not need to take on at this time.
Have Budget Constraints
As with any home renovation project, cost is always a consideration. A full window replacement cost may strain your budget beyond what you are able to consider. Window inserts are a cost-effective way to upgrade your windows. Choosing high-end inserts built with quality materials, like those offered by Climate Seal, makes this type of upgrade even more attractive.
Want Quicker Turnaround with Less Disruption
Let’s face it, pulling out your windows and going down to the studs for a full replacement is not going to be an easy project. It is the type of project that can also lead to something even bigger once it gets going. For example, tearing down to the studs can often lead to needing to replace the siding, at least around the window frame. This all means more time and more disruption in your home for the duration. Window inserts have a much faster turnaround and far less disruption. If you opt for a high-end window insert this turnaround time can be even better, much like the ease of installation of Climate Seal inserts.
Full Frame Vs. Insert Window Replacement: Key Takeaways
As with most home improvement projects, the choices you make from the available options have most to do with your budget and home needs. If your window frames are damaged or rotting or you want to significantly change the size, shape, or style of your windows, then a full window replacement may be the way to go in the full frame vs. window replacement comparison. However, if your frames are in good condition, you want to improve your home’s energy efficiency, and upgrade the glass and sash, then a window insert is a cost-effective and less disruptive option.
The best time of year to replace windows is during milder weather, usually in the spring or fall. Thinking about your options now and being ready to make your move when the time is right is to your advantage.
Contact us for a consultation on your window replacement options and to learn more about Climate Seal’s premier window inserts.